Jessica
Scherillo
Professor
Matyakubova
Eng201
The Corporate Corruption of
Politics and American Democracy
Abstract:
As young adults who are now granted the privilege to vote, it is essential that
we understand the processes in which political groups are funding their
campaigns. There are stipulations in which certain political parties,
specifically the Republican party, are finding loop holes in current
legislation to receive large endowments from large corporations. The
corporations are known as Super PACS. Finally, we will target how the
corruption in the political system is affecting the country and prove that it
is up to the everyday American's to exercise their right to vote in order to
hinder the bribery that occurs in elections every year. Hopefully, the audience
will be more educated about our political system.
The
Corporate Corruption of Politics and American Democracy
In the last presidential election
cycle, $1,977,700,000 was independently spent in support of Barrack Obama or Mitt
Romney, $828 million of which was raised by political action committees (PACs).
This money, enough to send 54,100 students to an in-state public university for
free for four years, has since diminished, leaving nothing behind except
irrelevant advertisements and discarded junk mail. Now, in anticipation the
upcoming election, the Koch brothers have announced a pledge of $899,000,000 in
support of republican candidates, easily overpowering the amount raised by the
entire Democratic party ensemble in 2012(Gold,2014). These funds, cobbled
together by covert donations spanning every county in America, and all legally
donated through super PACs, is only a fraction of what is shaping up to be the
most expensive election in United States history. They are also legally
grounded in Supreme Court precedent, specifically in the landmark case Citizens United v. FEC. This money,
courtesy of some of the most affluent individuals and corporations in modern
history, has changed the way Washington operates and is a corruptive factor in
American politics. Meaning, if our government is being enticed by dollar signs,
the government is becoming an unstable force.
American government has always
managed to shield itself from the corrosive influence of outside political
spending. At the turn of the twentieth century, following the scandal-ridden
administration of Ulysses S. Grant and the rise of capitalism, a series of
campaign finance acts were passed by Congress. Chief among these pieces of
legislation was the Federal Corrupt Practices Act (1910) which, for five
decades, thwarted any hints of external interfering in American politics. It
capped donations for Congressional and presidential elections, required
disclosure of all political donations, and was the first step towards a moral
code for those running for public office.
The major component this bill
lacked, however, was an enforcing body making sure that those in high office
did not violate the laws this act set. This was addressed by the passage of the
Federal Election Campaign Act (1972), which, in addition to tightening control
over donation limits and disclosure, created the Federal Election Commission
(FEC). This body became the “election police”, thoroughly enforcing strict
standards on the nation’s politicians. The "Election police" were set
into effect in order to mitigate nefarious actions within the election process.
Although they regulate spending and donations, large companies and higher
officials seem to be finding loop holes in the system.
Despite this seemingly thorough
safety net guarding against corruption, some loopholes were left exposed. The
Federal Election Campaign Act distinguished between two types of money used in
election spending – hard money, and soft money. Hard money was the funding that
was donated by official organizations that kept thorough records on who
contributed how much and when, while soft money was unlimited, under the radar
funding used for “party building activities”(Dodd-Frank,2010). This loose
terminology allowed for candidates to use this source of money for ads against
Republicans and against Democrats, rather than certain politicians (therefore
meeting the party-building activity requirement), and also provided a source of
uncapped financial backing. In order to address this, Congress passed the
Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act (BCRA) in 2002, which banned all soft money donations
and also prohibited corporations from broadcasting advertisements in favor of
certain candidates sixty days before general elections.
This intricate, well-crafted system
effectively filtered corporate influence out of politics. Cumulatively,
approximately $620 million were spent on presidential elections from 1990 (the
earliest year available with such statistics) until 2008 (the last election year
before the rise of super PACs), with all of the money being donated
responsibly, accountably, and accurately through the FEC. However, in 2008, a
conservative lobbying group named Citizens United announced planned to release
a film critical of Hillary Clinton less than thirty days before the Democratic
primary election, a move that directly violated the BCRA(Overby,2015). The
group was prohibited from doing so and, based on the rationale that this
prohibition violated the group’s free speech rights, took its case to court. Citizens United v. Federal Election
Commission made its way to the Supreme Court, where the justices ruled that
a ban on independent expenditures involving politicians (such as the Hillary
movie) were a breach of the First Amendment rights of non-profits. Additionally,
this ruling established the precedent that corporations , regardless of their
status as non-profit or for-profit , held the same rights as everyday
Americans, and they could not be stopped from spending money on politics
indirectly.
The Citizens United case paved the
road for the establishment of supersized political action committees. With the
high court’s blessing, corporations, wealthy individuals, and those who did not
wish to be identified began pouring money into a bottomless cauldron designed
to conceal donors. Organizations such as political actions committees, that had
been active since the 1980’s, restructured themselves into groups of shell
companies, for-profit and non-profit activist groups, and explored other
loophole-finding measures that exploited standing finance law in order to mask
those who contributed to the funding. Abiding by the Citizens United decision,
these super PACs expended their funds independently of the candidates, but
especially in the months leading up to Election Day, such divisions all but
disappeared.
Late in the election season,
candidates have sufficiently presented their platforms so that no such
coordination is necessary. In essence, the super PACs and candidates are openly
communicating through public announcements, websites, and speeches, all while
technically abiding by the no “direct communications” limitation. Furthermore, the
rules concerning coordination between candidates and PACs apply only to
candidates who have announced their intention to run for office. In preparation
for the 2016 election, candidates who have yet to formally announce have sent
their campaign-managers-to-be to run super PACs already harvesting tens of
millions of dollars, therefore coordinating directly (Healy, Confessore, 2015).
Such expansive networks have been
proven to exist and have a substantial impact on the political process. In
2012, “independent expenditures” were
responsible for over $1 billion in support of candidates, and $828 million of
it was raised by super PACs (the difference represents organizations and donors
that spent money independently of candidates, but not through super PACs)
(Center for Responsive Politics). About half of this money came from an
organization helmed by two of the richest men alive, Charles and David Koch
(Gold, 2014). This operation is important not only because of its singularity
in terms of its extent and scope, but also because of the extensive legal
barriers put in place in order to conceal the donors behind the alliance. Limited Liability Companies, otherwise known
as LLC’s, swapped money back and forth dozens of times, disappeared and
reappeared under different monikers, and confused the paper trail, making the
money nearly impossible to trace. These entities, which are not considered
separate businesses and therefore do not have to report taxes but rather simply
add profits or losses onto the balance sheet of a parent organization, served
as de facto banks and cash turnstiles for the Koch brother’s network (Gold,
2014).
Although the candidates backed by
the Koch brothers did not win the 2012 election, there is still evidence of the
effect corporate interfering has had in American politics. In the 2014 midterm
elections, $585 million was spent on “independent expenditures”, more than half
of which went to the Republican party and its candidates. The outcome was a large
victory for conservative politicians who received nearly $171 million in
support from the financial sector alone, which includes wealthy individuals,
banks, and organizations like super PACs (Center for Responsive Politics). Following
this domination on Capitol Hill, right wing lawmakers quickly introduced
legislation proposing to repeal critical parts of post-recession Dodd-Frank
legislation. These laws, passed in 2010 as a response the risky behavior of
banks that in part caused the Great Recession, dictated, among other things,
that banks could not place big bets with money involved in loans and other
securities (otherwise known as the Volker rule). After unsuccessfully attempting to pin this
legislation onto crucial government spending bills, Republicans fell six votes
shy of letting Wall Street run unchecked and according to pre-recession
standards (Ackerman, 2015). Whether or not these efforts had a correlation to
the money the financial sector contributed in 2014, or the anticipated funding
in 2016, is not backed by concrete evidence, but the timing could not be more perfect.
The presidential election in 2016 is
shaping up to be the most expensive in history. The $889 million donated by the
Koch political network matches the entire amount of money spent by the
Democrats in 2012, and then some. This is only a fraction of what is expected
to be spent next year, but already, frontrunners are speaking against this
flood of money. Hillary Clinton has made eliminating the flow of “big money”
one of the “four pillars” of her campaign, going as far as calling for a
constitutional amendment (Overby, 2015). Although this may be her intention,
there is little doubt that any candidate without a "fat wallet" will
stand a chance against the Republican funds in the election, so it seems that
Clinton is a proponent of “Do as I say and not as I do”.
Much of the original purpose of soft
money financing was to mobilize voters and support Election Day turnouts.
However, if this was ever the intended consequence, the results have been very
bad. Despite spending over half a billion dollars in order to “mobilize
voters”, 2014 turnout was the lowest midterm turnout since 1942. Just over
thirty-six percent of the population followed its civic duty to cast a ballot,
and Indiana saw a mere twenty-eight percent of voters come to the polls
(DelReal, 2014). Perhaps this is due to the increased independence young voters
feel, which translates into political laziness. It could be a general political
lack of concern Americans feel after the record bias Congress showed in its
previous term, notching a 14% general approval rating (Riffkin, 2014). Although
it is only possible to wonder, what is doubtless is that the effect of the
record amounts of money being spent on elections and politics is not producing
a more socially responsible, participating society.
The funding flood overtaking our
nation has far-reaching implications. First, it brings America as close to
public extortion as it has ever been. The Supreme Court’s confirmation of
commercial speech counting as free speech protected under the First Amendment
has transformed the political landscape into one which sells privilege to the
highest bidder. As mentioned earlier, Wall Street donations to the Republican
party have been evidently followed by attempts to repeal crucial financial
regulation law. Moreover, dysfunction and conflict within the Federal Election
Commission has essentially left campaign finance regulation reliant on
integrity of candidates, with one of the body’s commissioners stating that “the
likelihood of laws being enforced is slim” (Lichtblau, 2015). Secondly, money
coming in from both sides of the aisle has drowned out the voice of voters.
Congress only managed to pass 56 bills in 2013, choosing to play politics and
give an ear to those willing to pay rather than enact meaningful legislation
despite record-low approval ratings. Third, the economic results of Citizens
United is the superhuman status of corporations in America. Although they have
the same rights that physical human beings have, these multi-billion dollar
entities are not subject to the same criminal, ethical, or moral standards as
physical human beings. Therefore, they receive all the benefits associated with
being an American, with the ability to pay their way out of the responsibilities.
All of these pitfalls have concluded
in disaster. Both young and old voters have begun to see democracy with
skepticism and disengage with it, rather than attempt to rescue it. Inevitably,
this will lead to business replacing the voter. The questions at the center of
the issue of campaign finance are much bigger than politics. They are not about
free speech, as some proponents have suggested, because America is the only
place where Nazis and the Klu Klux Klan can march down the streets of a city. They
are not about equal treatment, because corporations do not share the same
burdens, responsibilities, and are not entitled to the same privileges as
citizens. What they are about, is whether we will be able to maintain the
future of this country the way our forefathers have expected us to. At stake is
the blood, sweat, and tears of hundreds of thousands of veterans, millions of
immigrants seeking a better life for their children, and even millions more
Americans who tirelessly built the foundation of this country. The question of
this issue is, if we will allow the growing 1% to abuse the American Dream in
the name of profit yet again? We can speak up through the power of the vote,
and rid the country of those representatives who forget the principles of this
nation. In order to adjust this issue, we must take advantage of the freedoms
that we are guaranteed ; the freedom to assemble and the freedom to speak, to
tell those who are on top that they are not able to
dictate the direction of this country.
Money
has always been kept at a safe distance from Washington D.C. The Federal
Corrupt Practices Act, the Federal Elections Campaign Act, and the Bipartisan
Campaign Reform Act were the products of careful efforts to keep corporations
and corrosive influences out of politics. The precedent set in Citizens United managed to overturn
nearly a century of meticulous regulation by exposing loopholes in the law and
outright overturning parts of the aforementioned acts. The election cycle in
2016 is set to hit a record high in terms of money spent, yet predictions for
voter turnout remain dismally low. With the immense power wielded by Wall
Street through its wealth, and some politicians promising to counter that
influence and restrict to pre-Citizen United levels if elected, a showdown is
set to occur next year. This showdown will decide the fate of American
democracy, and if it will survive the overwhelming surge of money coming
through its gates.
References
"Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA)." United
States Dept. of Justice, n.d.
"The Federal Election Campaign Act - Boundless Open
Textbook." Boundless. N.p., n.d. "Campaign Finance Law Quick
Reference for Reporters." Federal Election Commission. United States Dept.
of Justice, n.d.
"Reports." Opensecrets RSS. Center for Responsive
Politics, n.d.
"Outside Spending." Opensecrets RSS. Center for
Responsive Politics, n.d.
"2014 Election Overview." Opensecrets RSS. Center
for Responsive Politics, n.d.
Ackerman, Andrew. "House Republican Push to Roll Back
Wall Street Regulations Fails." WSJ. The Wall Street Journal, Jan 7, 2015.
Ashkenas, Jeremy, and Matthew Ericson. "The 2012 Money
Race: Compare the Candidates." The New York Times. The New York Times, Dec
21, 2012.
Delreal, Jose. "Voter Turnout in 2014 Was the Lowest
since WWII." Washington Post. The Washington Post, Nov 10, 2014.
"Dodd-Frank Financial Regulatory Reform Bill Definition
| Investopedia." Investopedia. N.p., July 21, 2010
Gold, Matea. "Inside the Koch-backed Political Network,
an Operation Designed to Shield Donors." Washington Post. The Washington
Post, Jan 5, 2014.
Healy, Patrick, and Nicholas Confessore. "Head Start
for Jeb Bush Campaign Is Part of Scott Walker’s Plan." The New York Times.
The New York Times, Apr 27, 2015.
Lichtblau, Eric. "F.E.C. Can't Curb 2016 Election
Abuse, Commission Chief Says." The New York Times. The New York Times, May
2, 2015.
Novak, Viveca. "Overall Spending Inches Up in 2014:
Megadonors Equip Outside Groups to Capture a Bigger Share of the Pie."
Opensecrets RSS. Center for Responsive Politics, Oct 29, 2014.
Overby, Peter. "Hillary Clinton Supports Amendment To
Get Hidden Money Out Of Politics." NPR. National Public Radio, Apr 17,
2015.
Riffkin, Rebecca. "2014 U.S. Approval of Congress
Remains Near All-Time Low." Gallup Polling. Gallup, Dec 14, 2014.
No comments:
Post a Comment